Palestinian political parties in Israel have backed opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot to replace Benjamin Netanyahu, despite Eisenkot’s role in the Israeli war cabinet during the devastating military campaign in Gaza.
Eisenkot, a former Israeli military chief, served in Netanyahu’s emergency war cabinet from October 2023 until June 2024.
His political record has raised questions about whether replacing Netanyahu would bring meaningful changes for Palestinians living in Israel, the occupied territories or the diaspora.
In an opinion article for Middle East Eye, Joseph Massad argues that Palestinian parties risk helping Israel overcome its political crisis without securing substantial Palestinian rights.
How Palestinian Political Rights Became Divided
The fragmentation of Palestinian political rights has roots in the events of 1948, when hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were displaced during the Nakba.
Palestinians were subsequently divided between those remaining inside Israel, communities in the West Bank and Gaza, and refugees living elsewhere.
Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and Gaza in 1967 created further legal and political divisions, including separate arrangements for Palestinians in East Jerusalem.
Massad argues that the Palestinian Liberation Organization’s gradual shift towards prioritising the territories occupied in 1967 weakened the broader struggle for Palestinian rights.
The PLO’s 1988 declaration of independence and the 1993 Oslo Accords reinforced a political framework centred on the West Bank and Gaza.
According to Massad, this approach marginalised the rights of Palestinian refugees and citizens of Israel, particularly the right of return and demands for full equality.
The 2026 Election Results Changed the Political Balance
Israel’s October 27 election produced no parliamentary majority for either Netanyahu or Eisenkot.
Netanyahu’s Likud won 27 seats, while Eisenkot’s Yashar party secured 21.
The Palestinian Arab parties won a combined 19 seats, giving them a potentially decisive role in determining who could form the next government.
After receiving recommendations from 67 lawmakers, Eisenkot was formally backed by Palestinian Arab parties and tasked with forming a government by President Isaac Herzog on November 8.
Why Palestinian Parties Backed Eisenkot
Palestinian political leaders have defended their support for Eisenkot as a necessary step towards removing Netanyahu’s government.
Sami Abu Shehadeh, leader of the National Democratic Assembly, acknowledged that Eisenkot was not a desirable candidate but argued that extraordinary political circumstances had left Palestinian parties with difficult choices.
“We do not have easy choices.” Sami Abu Shehadeh, explaining his party’s decision
However, Eisenkot has maintained that he wants to establish a Zionist government and has shown reluctance to include Palestinian Arab parties as full coalition partners.
He has nevertheless indicated that a minority government supported by Palestinian parties from outside the coalition could be considered.
Palestinian parties could provide the votes needed to replace Netanyahu without necessarily receiving direct representation in the new government.
Massad questions whether this arrangement would strengthen Palestinian political influence or simply help establish another Israeli government committed to existing state policies.
The Limits of Palestinian Participation in Israeli Politics
Palestinian citizens of Israel have faced decades of institutional discrimination, land restrictions, unequal public services and political exclusion.
While parliamentary participation has helped secure some municipal funding and public resources, major inequalities remain.
Israeli rights organisation Adalah has documented numerous laws and policies that discriminate against Palestinian citizens.
Massad argues that decades of participation in the Knesset have failed to fundamentally change these structures.
He points to the experience of 2020, when Palestinian parties recommended former military chief Benny Gantz to lead a government.
Gantz ultimately joined Netanyahu in a unity government and later served as defence minister during Israel’s 2021 military offensive in Gaza.
The episode illustrates, in Massad’s assessment, the limited influence Palestinian parties can exercise over the policies of Israeli governing coalitions.
Mansour Abbas and the Coalition Dispute
The debate intensified after Israeli media reported that Mansour Abbas, leader of the United Arab List (Ra’am), was prepared to recognise Hamas as a terrorist organisation in exchange for genuine participation in a future coalition.
Abbas denied the report on November 11, saying he had made no such declaration.
He nevertheless maintained that Ra’am wanted to participate in the next government and supported the dismantling of Hamas under a proposed political settlement.
The dispute highlighted the difficult negotiations facing Palestinian parties seeking a role in an Eisenkot-led administration.
Would Replacing Netanyahu Change Palestinian Rights?
The central question raised by Massad is whether supporting Eisenkot would produce meaningful improvements for Palestinians or merely stabilise Israel’s political system.
He argues that replacing Netanyahu would not, by itself, address the occupation, Palestinian refugee rights, discrimination against Palestinian citizens of Israel or the destruction in Gaza.
For Massad, the election represents a critical moment to reconsider whether parliamentary alliances with Israeli governing parties can deliver substantive Palestinian rights.
His position is that Palestinian political parties should pursue alternatives that strengthen Palestinian rights collectively rather than help resolve Israel’s governing crisis.
Original opinion: Joseph Massad, Middle East Eye, 13 November 2026.
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Sunna Files News.