Despite extensive bombardment, powerful explosions and attempts to flood underground passages, military operations have failed to comprehensively destroy tunnel networks in Gaza, Lebanon and Iran, according to an Israeli engineering specialist.
Dr Amichai Mittelman, a researcher in the Department of Civil Engineering at Ariel University, told Israeli newspaper Maariv that underground infrastructure remains exceptionally difficult to eliminate. Many networks have survived intense military operations, with damage often confined to individual sections.
In an interview with journalist Moshe Cohen, Mittelman explained that tunnels offer two major military advantages: protection against attacks and explosions, and the ability to conceal infrastructure from surveillance.
“There are no magic solutions for destroying tunnels.”Dr Amichai Mittelman | Israeli Engineering Researcher
Gaza’s Underground Network: A Challenge Israel Underestimated
For years, Israeli security efforts focused primarily on detecting tunnels, particularly those crossing the Gaza border, rather than understanding the full scale of the underground network.
Mittelman said the extent of Gaza’s tunnel infrastructure became a major surprise following 7 October 2023, prompting Israel to shift its focus from detection towards comprehensive destruction.
Gaza’s tunnels vary considerably in size. Some are narrow passages, while others are large enough to accommodate Hamas command facilities. The scale and diversity of the network have complicated Israel’s attempts to dismantle it.
Why Flooding and Massive Explosions Failed
Mittelman identified three principal approaches used against Gaza’s tunnels, each facing substantial engineering or financial limitations.
Attempts to pump water underground failed to achieve their objective. Water escaped through openings or surrounding groundwater systems, exposing shortcomings in the engineering preparations.
Powerful explosions produced dramatic clouds of smoke but generally caused localised collapses. Much of the blast energy dissipated through the interconnected passages rather than destroying entire networks.
Filling tunnels with concrete was considered more effective because blocked sections are harder to reopen. However, the enormous material requirements and associated costs make large-scale implementation difficult.
Mittelman estimated that filling a 1,000-kilometre network with passages two metres wide would require approximately two million cubic metres of concrete, at an estimated material price of 500 Israeli shekels per cubic metre, excluding transport and contractor costs.
He also noted that Gaza’s relatively soft kurkar soil has contributed to the survival of substantial sections of the network, allowing Hamas to rehabilitate damaged passages.
Lebanon’s Tunnels Present a Different Obstacle
Hezbollah’s underground infrastructure in southern Lebanon presents a different engineering challenge. Unlike Gaza’s passages, many Lebanese tunnels are excavated through solid rock.
According to Mittelman, even enormous quantities of explosives have failed to destroy these networks completely. Instead, attacks have generally produced limited structural damage and collapses that can be repaired.
The central obstacle is not simply locating an underground network. It is ensuring that the destruction of individual sections permanently disables the wider infrastructure.
Iran’s Mountain Fortifications Are Even Harder to Penetrate
Iran represents an even more demanding challenge because of its mountainous terrain and extensive experience in underground engineering.
Mittelman suggested that Hamas and Hezbollah may have drawn inspiration from Iran’s approach to underground warfare. Tehran has developed deep facilities, including missile complexes commonly described as “missile cities” and nuclear installations, reportedly reaching depths of 100 metres or more.
The Israeli researcher questioned whether successive strikes using bunker-busting bombs could reliably penetrate such deeply protected facilities. He also acknowledged that operating missiles from these depths creates logistical challenges that can restrict launch frequency.
Iran’s extensive experience constructing mountain and transport tunnels, he added, also supports its ability to restore damaged underground connections.
Mittelman’s overall assessment was that the laws of physics and currently available military capabilities do not provide a reliable means of achieving the complete destruction of extensive underground tunnel networks.